Exclusive: DOE corruption-appointed and elected officials should face prison time

An exhaustive review of 350+ pages of leaked emails regarding the Obama administration’s handling of the various green-energy loan and grant programs makes several things very clear: they lied, engaged in favoritism, and rushed application approvals to suit the political agenda of the White House. At the same time, worthy projects that went through a complete due diligence process were denied or ultimately withdrawn, as the lengthy approval process “taxed investors’ patience”—as was the case with Aptera Motors, which worked closely with the DOE for two years.

Paul Wilbur, President and CEO at Aptera, didn’t think they were treated unfairly. He told me, “At the end of the day, we couldn’t get through the process.” But, he admits, he hasn’t read the emails.

Aptera was trying to build a very efficient electric vehicle with an under-$30K price point. Wilbur met with Secretary Chu, who could see the value in the technology. But our research shows that value was not the deciding factor in which projects got funded and which ones didn’t. Wilbur reports that he didn’t donate to any candidate. He wanted to keep the whole process clean and do what was “good for America.”

The report from the House Oversight Committee says Aptera first applied for an ATVM loan in December of 2008 and “shut down on December 2, 2011.”  The report implies that Aptera was led on: “After numerous negotiations with DOE, in September 2011, Aptera received a conditional loan commitment of $150 million if the company was able to raise $80 million privately.” And: “The loans given to Fisker and Tesla gave Aptera hope that DOE would eventually act on their application. More importantly, since the DOE continued to engage with the company throughout the time period, management was convinced that DOE was interested and willing to provide financing for the company.”

Aptera’s 100% US technology has since been sold to a Chinese company.

Aptera was applying for an Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing loan (ATVM). Only five loans were given out through the program, and all have political ramifications. Christine Lakatos, who has worked with me on the green-energy, crony-corruption reports I’ve written, has done thorough research on the topic. She has read each and every one of the 350+ pages of emails released on October 31 and has written a blog post specifically addressing the ATVM program and its hijinks. As she cites, Fisker and Tesla (which Romney referenced in the first debate) got loans in 2010, and then the Vehicle Production Group’s loan was the only ATVM loan closed in 2011; all have ties to Obama bundlers. The other two ATVM loans went to Ford and Nissan—both of which, according to the House report, “were heavily engaged in negotiations with the Administration over fuel economy standards for model years 2012-2016 at the time the DOE was considering their applications. Both companies eventually expressed publicly their support for these standards, which the Administration described as the ‘Historic Agreement.’”

Armed with the sweeping knowledge of the House reports and subsequent hearings, evidence from DOE staffers (many of whom were appointed by Obama), Lakatos’ research, and personal experience, a different ATVM applicant has now taken its case to court citing “corruption and negligence.”

On November 16, 2012, XP Technology filed a lawsuit against the federal government concerning the DOE’s denial of XP Technology’s loan guarantee application. The complaint alleges: “criminal activities did take place by DOE staff and affiliates.” A November 23 press release announces that XP Technology is now represented by Cause of Action, “a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that uses investigative, legal, and communication tools to educate the public on how government accountability and transparency protects taxpayer interests and economic activity.”

According to the document filed on November 16, “Plaintiffs backgrounds include extensive issued patents on seminal technologies in use world-wide, White House and Congressional commendations and an engineering team of highly experienced auto-makers. Plaintiff brought a vehicle design which was proposed as the longest range, safest, lowest cost electric vehicle, to be built in America in order to deliver extensive American jobs nationwide. No other applicant, or award ‘winner’, has succeeded in meeting, or intending to meet, that milestone. XP Technology developed a patented lightweight, low-cost, long-range, electric vehicle using air-expanded foam-skinned material for a portion of the polymer body and received numerous patents, acclaim and superior computer modeling metrics over any competing solution. XP presented a vast set of letters of support to DOE from pending customers. Major auto-industry facilities and engineers had joined forces to bring the vehicle to the defense, commercial and consumer market.”

Over the weekend, we had an exclusive interview, on condition of anonymity, with a senior official at XP Technology about the lawsuit and the experience.

He reported: “Staff from within the DOE have provided evidence which is quite compelling.” As Aptera’s Wilbur made clear, the individuals within the DOE were very thorough. One of the emails, in the 350+ pages, was from Secretary Chu himself in which he criticized staffers for taking a “principled stand,” which held up the approval process of projects the White House wanted advanced. Another indicated that the pressure to rush was coming from “above the agency.” Overall, the emails show that projects were rushed so that announcements could coincide with visits, speeches, and photo ops—as well as providing talking points for the president.

Our XP source told us “We experienced, and have been provided evidence of, applicant submissions and reviews being modified in order to benefit some and disadvantage others, and the business connections between the different parties associated with the ones that benefited is quite extraordinary.”  The leaked emails support this accusation, specifically regarding the “business connections.” In her post, Lakatos calls it “green fraternizing.” The emails show that certain applicants and decision makers went bike riding together, had coffee meetings, sleepovers, beer summits, parties, dinners, and fundraisers.

While he didn’t provide us with a name, the XP official said, “We experienced a senior senator blockading our efforts and then providing favors to a competitor, which then benefited his family financially.” The discovery the lawsuit will provide will expose the “senior senator,” but our previous research shows that Senator Harry Reid’s actions seem to fit the XP official’s comment.

XP Technology believes that “DOE officials changed the first-come-first-served published rules and standards of the funding in order to take applicants in order of who they favored and who had purchased the most influence instead of the order in which they applied, as required.”

Having extensively studied the DOE’s various loan programs, including the ATVM, Lakatos and I agree with our source’s startling conclusion: “Based on the evidence provided by investigators, and experienced directly by our team, it is hard to imagine that at least one or more elected, or appointed, officials might not be seeing measures ranging from censure or even federal prison time.”

Time, the lawsuit, and subsequent investigation will tell.

While the House Oversight Committee has been digging deeply into the mismanagement and corruption of the green energy loans, the media has paid little attention. Other than our report, the October 31 release of the emails cited here received virtually no news reporting. Even the Fox News Channel ignored the story. The plight of promising companies like Aptera and XP Technology would have gone unnoticed if not for the lawsuit. The legal complaint attracted attention.

On November 16, the Heritage Foundation broke the XP story: “A lawsuit filed in federal court on Wednesday alleges mass favoritism in the Department of Energy’s decisions to award federal grants to major car companies to develop electric vehicles, according to a legal complaint obtained by Scribe.”

On November 19, Lakatos, whose work is listed as “evidence” in the legal complaint, received a call from Fox News’ Gary Gastelu—who reported on the story on November 20. The next day, Fox News covered the lawsuit on America’s Newsroom. Even the Drudge Report picked up on the story.

XP has a litigation website on which the company states: “The case has nothing to do with complaining about not getting the loans. It has everything to do with HOW the applicants didn’t get the loans!” They are communicating with other applicants about participating in the lawsuit.

The XP story and subsequent media coverage offers a lesson for others—especially industries who have been wronged by the Obama Administration’s practices (such as energy). The lawsuit may—or may not—send officials to federal prison, as our XP source suggests; but it could go a long way to winning in the court of public opinion.



The author of Energy Freedom, Marita Noon serves as the executive director for Energy Makes America Great Inc. and the companion educational organization, the Citizens’ Alliance for Responsible Energy (CARE). Together they work to educate the public and influence policy makers regarding energy, its role in freedom, and the American way of life. Combining energy, news, politics, and, the environment through public events, speaking engagements, and media, the organizations’ combined efforts serve as America’s voice for energy.

Photo credit: charlesfettinger (Creative Commons)


  1. One more massive Obama scandal ignored by the sycophants in the media. On the other hand I guess the "folks" who got free Obama phones could care less. Rush was spot on when he said it was tough to compete against Santa Claus.

  2. Donald Mather says:

    Maybe someonewill learn that you need be honest to be legal.?????

  3. With an irrelevant congress and corrupt DOJ don't look for anything to happen. Harry Reid needs to be put in prison just on the basis of being corrupt and worthless. He has failed to do his job as head of the senate, yet like a corrupt union boss he retains his power.

  4. John Stewart says:

    If this action comes to fruition, prison overcrowding would hit a new high.

  5. When we get Obama out of there, these weasels are going to have hell to pay.

    • Why do we have to "wait" for Obama to be out of there? Why are we impotent? Why are our hands tied? He is traitorous, Marxist product of his rearing and of the Chicago Progressive thugs.

      Why won't our elected representatives face down this Benedict Arnold ? Why won't even a few stand up like patriots and call for Obama's impeachment?

      All Obama's appointees and their staffs are his Gestapo army. The "Main Stream Media" are his Goebals propaganda machine. The minorities are his footmen who allow themselves to be used as fodder when they trade their self-respect, their independence, and their individual freedom for a dependency based on the Democrat handouts.

      America is entering its "Dark Age" under this rapid rush to Socialism and State control of everybody and everything! Obama is out to destroy the USA and he is succeeding with the help of many ignorant, useful idiots and the willing sheeple who won't stop their denial that he is bringing us to ruin.

      We have to wake up and take back our Country from the seditious crowd that is "in control". They don't deserve to be called "Americans"!

  6. Just one of many where Congressional oversight has failed miserably Congress… democrats and republicans, you are allowing your legislative powers to be stripped from you at a rapid rate. There should be NO EPA mandates or third party suits that allow the EPA to not only make the assumption that said suits are valid ,but to fund the third party's pursuing said suit. These actions by pass congressional oversight and have cost the tax payer and all businesses a fortune…All of it ill conceived ,much of it fraudulent in nature, and with the EPA's analysis many times biased to the extreme. Congress if you fail to react in a bi-partisan manner to recognize and protect your country from an agenda that will surely destroy our great nation… Then your "party first" tunnel vision will not only cripple our nation ,but you Mr. / Mrs Senator and or Representative may soon find that indeed you no longer wield any power,as you have allowed it all to be usurped by the executive branch and it's tendrils. " If you don't use it you lose it "

  7. This warranty program doesn’t need a receipt or possibly
    a dated proof purchase. True prosperity need to be built on
    solid foundations. Because in the incredibly high longevity of power tools, Craftsman would be
    the official tool utilised by NASCAR.

  8. Greetings, There’s no doubt that your web site might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine however when opening in I.E., it has some overlapping issues.
    I just wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!

    Besides that, fantastic blog!

  9. It’s hard to find experienced people about this topic, however, you seem
    like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

  10. The golfer of today, with few exceptions (John Daly.

    Many seniors feel discouraged because they have chronic health conditions or
    are concerned about injuries or falls and thus do not exercise as much as they should.
    You have to not practice the craft of personal training
    without having liability insurance in place.

  11. Besides the proper tools practically every on line marketing effort can be
    broken into 4 primary tasks. With some effort it should be very possible to find a
    decent combination of price and quality. Most of the plans, apart from the Starter plan have databases either in SQL
    or My – SQL.

  12. Here are some key signs that it’s time to start shopping for a new web hosting company:
    . Most reliable hosting companies will offer Frontpage hosting these days.

    The actions that you are taking now is sending potential buyers to the competition.

  13. I blog frequently and I really appreciate your information. This great
    article has truly peaked my interest. I’m going to bookmark your
    website and keep checking for new details about once per
    week. I opted in for your Feed too.

  14. You are encouraged to eat as much food as it takes to make you satisfied so that you do not suffer from any food cravings.
    This went on for a very long time, until somewhere along the line (roughly
    10,000 years ago, actually) agriculture came into
    existence and grains (wheat, pasta, rice,
    corn, rye, barley)A became an integral part of the human diet.
    Place the mixture in a container and place in the freezer.

  15. Sweet blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News.
    Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
    I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get
    there! Thank you

  16. While today we have many dairy products, calcium intake is
    lower and this is due to low intake of foods that are naturally in the mineral,
    for example, nuts and seeds. If you have been trying to get your family to eat more healthfully,
    you likely realize how very difficult it is to find recipes that contain only healthy, natural ingredients.
    And just remember that as close as you can get to this lifestyle choice, the benefits will start to appear.

  17. But if you go directly for professional support
    at a store, you could end leaving with the latest model and a
    big hole in your pocket. For instance using Augmented Reality, you would be able to
    take your phone out when looking at something you don’t understand and get
    instant information regarding what it is. While carrying them
    you also think about fashion and being able carry all the important things in an easy way.

  18. Attractive section of content. I jst stumbled upon your weblog
    and in accession capital to assert that I get actually enjoyed account your blog
    posts. Any way I’ll be subscrbing to your augment and even I achievement yoou access consistently quickly.

  19. I absolutely love your blog and find the majority of
    your post’s to be just what I’m looking for. Do you offer guest
    writers to write content for you personally?

    I wouldn’t mind writing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write in relation to here.
    Again, awesome web site!

Speak Your Mind

Connect with Facebook